Readers Speak Up for Patients Who Can’t, and for Kids With Disabilities
Letters to the Editor is a periodic feature. We welcome all comments and will publish a selection. We edit for length and clarity and require full names.
A reporter at Just the News shared our article about a man whose organs were nearly harvested while he was still alive:
Disinformed consent is standard operating procedure in the organ donation industry. And much of medicine. “The sisters said hospital staffers told them the movements were involuntary.” https://t.co/tDSp4oCNgL
— Greg Piper, Washington, D.C.
Too Close a Call With Organ Donation
During my third year as a medical student, I was part of a trauma surgery rotation when we received a patient with severe abdominal injuries from a gunshot wound. After a long night of stabilization efforts, he remained alive the following day. However, the medical team concluded that he was likely brain-dead and a candidate for organ donation. This situation was detailed in the article, “A Surgical Team Was About To Harvest This Man’s Organs — Until His Doctor Intervened” (Sept. 12).
As preparations for organ donation began, I noticed some movement from the patient. As a third-year student, my observations were often dismissed, but I felt compelled to speak up. I approached one of the surgeons and expressed my concern that the patient might be trying to communicate.
My comments were brushed aside as mere spinal reflexes. Yet, I couldn’t shake the feeling that there was more to it. After rounds, I returned to the patient’s bedside and asked, “Are you able to hear me?” To my astonishment, he attempted to respond despite being intubated and on a ventilator. It became evident that he was not brain-dead.
I quickly alerted the surgical team, who reevaluated the patient. They discovered that he had a bullet lodged in his brain, which had gone unnoticed amidst the chaos of his other injuries. A CT scan confirmed the bullet’s presence, and a neurosurgery team intervened to alleviate the pressure in his skull. Remarkably, he began to regain consciousness and interacted with his family, who had feared the worst.
Although he ultimately succumbed to his injuries, the experience left a lasting impression on me. It highlighted the critical importance of thorough evaluations in medical settings, especially regarding organ donation.
As someone with a family member on multiple transplant lists, I understand the urgency of organ donation. However, it is vital that we uphold the dignity of every individual, ensuring that no one is rushed into decisions that could compromise their humanity.
— Michael J. Mina, Boston
A radiologist in Denver also posted his thoughts about the article on the social platform X:
This is very rare in the world of transplant surgery. But it should be “never,” rather than “rare.” https://t.co/yJ3BZkLXND
— Paul Hsieh, Denver
Speaking for Kids With Disabilities
I read the article “Parents Fear Losing Disability Protections as Trump Slashes Civil Rights Office” (Sept. 15) with a renewed sense of purpose. The potential dismantling of the U.S. Department of Education is concerning, especially considering my own journey as a recipient of special education services after a severe motorcycle accident.
At 18, I suffered a traumatic brain injury that required extensive rehabilitation. Thanks to dedicated therapists and educators, I graduated with a bachelor’s degree and later earned two master’s degrees. I enjoyed a fulfilling career, advocating for social work and public health.
Children with disabilities have much to contribute when given the opportunity. It is crucial for policymakers to recognize the value of inclusive education and support systems.
— Brason Lee, Sacramento, California
A Democratic member of Congress weighs in on X:
Disabled kids are facing great challenges in their schools, and the dismantling of the Department of Education will only worsen these struggles. It is vital we support our students of all backgrounds. https://t.co/pN1cAnRXOd
— Grace Meng, Queens borough of New York City
A Hole in ‘Big Loopholes’?
The article “Big Loopholes in Hospital Charity Care Programs Mean Patients Still Get Stuck With the Tab” (Sept. 25) by Michelle Andrews missed a crucial point: while hospitals receive government funding for charity care, private practice providers do not. This omission overlooks the financial realities faced by specialists.
— Roger Broome, Galena, Ohio
A science writer in New York shared her thoughts on X about our coverage of Trump administration policies:
These clinics were already stretched thin before the new guidance. That seems unlikely to change given the major staffing cuts at HRSA, which directs funding to community clinics and other HHS programs. H/t @sjtribble and @HMLLarweh at @KFFHealthNews https://t.co/ngit8sP9X8
— Lauren Schneider, New York City
When HRSA Hurts, Nursing Suffers
The Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) plays a crucial role in nurturing the healthcare workforce. With a looming shortage of healthcare professionals, it is essential to maintain HRSA’s funding and support. The agency manages Nursing Workforce Development Programs that are vital for education and recruitment, especially in underserved areas.
As a nurse educator, I have witnessed firsthand how these programs have strengthened the nursing pipeline. With an aging population and increasing healthcare needs, we must ensure a robust workforce capable of providing quality care.
Policymakers must prioritize HRSA in future budgets to sustain a strong healthcare workforce and ensure access to care for all.
— Patty Knecht, chief nursing officer of Ascend Learning/ATI Nursing Education, Downingtown, Pennsylvania
A Michigan reader expresses his opinion succinctly on social media:
Make America Ill Again https://t.co/DPFJtfB0fl
— Paul Hughes-Cromwick (Pooge), Ann Arbor, Michigan
Keeping PACE With Vulnerable Seniors
Elder homelessness is a pressing issue, as highlighted in the article “Health Care Groups Aim To Counter Growing ‘National Scandal’ of Elder Homelessness” (Aug. 18). Many seniors face precarious living situations, particularly in rural areas where poverty and chronic illness are prevalent.
The Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE) is designed to address these challenges. PACE programs can provide essential services, such as home repairs and heating installations, to help seniors remain in their homes safely.
To combat housing instability among older adults, it is imperative for policymakers to expand eligibility and empower PACE providers to act swiftly when issues arise. Investing in PACE can significantly reduce homelessness and enhance community-based care.
— Craig Worland, interim CEO and COO of One Senior Care, Erie, Pennsylvania
I recently came across an idea on Facebook about converting closed malls and shopping centers into affordable housing. This innovative approach could provide thousands of homes while revitalizing these spaces. Essential services could be included, creating vibrant communities. I hope this idea gains traction!
— Brenda Peters, Charlotte, North Carolina
Letters to the Editor is a periodic feature. We welcome all comments and will publish a selection. We edit for length and clarity and require full names.
A reporter at Just the News shared our article about a man whose organs were nearly harvested while he was still alive:
Disinformed consent is standard operating procedure in the organ donation industry. And much of medicine. “The sisters said hospital staffers told them the movements were involuntary.” https://t.co/tDSp4oCNgL
— Greg Piper, Washington, D.C.
Too Close a Call With Organ Donation
During my third year as a medical student, I was part of a trauma surgery rotation when we received a patient with severe abdominal injuries from a gunshot wound. After a long night of stabilization efforts, he remained alive the following day. However, the medical team concluded that he was likely brain-dead and a candidate for organ donation. This situation was detailed in the article, “A Surgical Team Was About To Harvest This Man’s Organs — Until His Doctor Intervened” (Sept. 12).
As preparations for organ donation began, I noticed some movement from the patient. As a third-year student, my observations were often dismissed, but I felt compelled to speak up. I approached one of the surgeons and expressed my concern that the patient might be trying to communicate.
My comments were brushed aside as mere spinal reflexes. Yet, I couldn’t shake the feeling that there was more to it. After rounds, I returned to the patient’s bedside and asked, “Are you able to hear me?” To my astonishment, he attempted to respond despite being intubated and on a ventilator. It became evident that he was not brain-dead.
I quickly alerted the surgical team, who reevaluated the patient. They discovered that he had a bullet lodged in his brain, which had gone unnoticed amidst the chaos of his other injuries. A CT scan confirmed the bullet’s presence, and a neurosurgery team intervened to alleviate the pressure in his skull. Remarkably, he began to regain consciousness and interacted with his family, who had feared the worst.
Although he ultimately succumbed to his injuries, the experience left a lasting impression on me. It highlighted the critical importance of thorough evaluations in medical settings, especially regarding organ donation.
As someone with a family member on multiple transplant lists, I understand the urgency of organ donation. However, it is vital that we uphold the dignity of every individual, ensuring that no one is rushed into decisions that could compromise their humanity.
— Michael J. Mina, Boston
A radiologist in Denver also posted his thoughts about the article on the social platform X:
This is very rare in the world of transplant surgery. But it should be “never,” rather than “rare.” https://t.co/yJ3BZkLXND
— Paul Hsieh, Denver
Speaking for Kids With Disabilities
I read the article “Parents Fear Losing Disability Protections as Trump Slashes Civil Rights Office” (Sept. 15) with a renewed sense of purpose. The potential dismantling of the U.S. Department of Education is concerning, especially considering my own journey as a recipient of special education services after a severe motorcycle accident.
At 18, I suffered a traumatic brain injury that required extensive rehabilitation. Thanks to dedicated therapists and educators, I graduated with a bachelor’s degree and later earned two master’s degrees. I enjoyed a fulfilling career, advocating for social work and public health.
Children with disabilities have much to contribute when given the opportunity. It is crucial for policymakers to recognize the value of inclusive education and support systems.
— Brason Lee, Sacramento, California
A Democratic member of Congress weighs in on X:
Disabled kids are facing great challenges in their schools, and the dismantling of the Department of Education will only worsen these struggles. It is vital we support our students of all backgrounds. https://t.co/pN1cAnRXOd
— Grace Meng, Queens borough of New York City
A Hole in ‘Big Loopholes’?
The article “Big Loopholes in Hospital Charity Care Programs Mean Patients Still Get Stuck With the Tab” (Sept. 25) by Michelle Andrews missed a crucial point: while hospitals receive government funding for charity care, private practice providers do not. This omission overlooks the financial realities faced by specialists.
— Roger Broome, Galena, Ohio
A science writer in New York shared her thoughts on X about our coverage of Trump administration policies:
These clinics were already stretched thin before the new guidance. That seems unlikely to change given the major staffing cuts at HRSA, which directs funding to community clinics and other HHS programs. H/t @sjtribble and @HMLLarweh at @KFFHealthNews https://t.co/ngit8sP9X8
— Lauren Schneider, New York City
When HRSA Hurts, Nursing Suffers
The Health Resources and Services Administration (HRSA) plays a crucial role in nurturing the healthcare workforce. With a looming shortage of healthcare professionals, it is essential to maintain HRSA’s funding and support. The agency manages Nursing Workforce Development Programs that are vital for education and recruitment, especially in underserved areas.
As a nurse educator, I have witnessed firsthand how these programs have strengthened the nursing pipeline. With an aging population and increasing healthcare needs, we must ensure a robust workforce capable of providing quality care.
Policymakers must prioritize HRSA in future budgets to sustain a strong healthcare workforce and ensure access to care for all.
— Patty Knecht, chief nursing officer of Ascend Learning/ATI Nursing Education, Downingtown, Pennsylvania
A Michigan reader expresses his opinion succinctly on social media:
Make America Ill Again https://t.co/DPFJtfB0fl
— Paul Hughes-Cromwick (Pooge), Ann Arbor, Michigan
Keeping PACE With Vulnerable Seniors
Elder homelessness is a pressing issue, as highlighted in the article “Health Care Groups Aim To Counter Growing ‘National Scandal’ of Elder Homelessness” (Aug. 18). Many seniors face precarious living situations, particularly in rural areas where poverty and chronic illness are prevalent.
The Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly (PACE) is designed to address these challenges. PACE programs can provide essential services, such as home repairs and heating installations, to help seniors remain in their homes safely.
To combat housing instability among older adults, it is imperative for policymakers to expand eligibility and empower PACE providers to act swiftly when issues arise. Investing in PACE can significantly reduce homelessness and enhance community-based care.
— Craig Worland, interim CEO and COO of One Senior Care, Erie, Pennsylvania
I recently came across an idea on Facebook about converting closed malls and shopping centers into affordable housing. This innovative approach could provide thousands of homes while revitalizing these spaces. Essential services could be included, creating vibrant communities. I hope this idea gains traction!
— Brenda Peters, Charlotte, North Carolina
